During this week’s session, host Julie F. Bacchini asked PPC professionals about their BFCM strategies and how they differ from their usual approach. She also explored whether they are managing any e-commerce accounts this holiday season and what clients are expecting from this year’s BFCM.
Q1: Are you managing any ecommerce accounts this holiday season? If so, what types of products are being sold?
I am a lead gen-only PPCer, so I am an observer this time of year. I did Ecomm once, and it was horrible. Mad respect for all of you doing that work during the holidays! @NeptuneMoon
Yep, have several ecomm clients, from Cat Furniture to Live Experiences. @ynotweb
I should add that the client was quite difficult that I worked on. A VC backed DTC brand. @NeptuneMoon
May I interest you in some of the finest ppc software that ever did be? @NeptuneMoon “BUDGET IS UNLIMITED IF YOU HIT GOALS” no it’s not you lying liars @Aaronlevy
@NeptuneMoon well, PE or VC-backed anything would suck @ynotweb
It was so bad. Maybe we need a “worst account I ever worked on” chat @NeptuneMoon
I must say I do prefer the lead gen clients this time of year. May have to drop some ecomm before next year’s BF/holiday season if I want to get back to my nice holiday schedule @ynotweb
We host Thanksgiving, so I have zero interest in having to look at accounts next Wed-Fri @NeptuneMoon
@NeptuneMoon Question 5 of “Worst account ever” chat can be “And how long did it take you to fire the client?” LOL @ynotweb
Yes! We’re managing a variety of eCom brands across different sectors and countries, from homeware and luxury bedding to lifestyle products and gifts. We’re now in full-on promo mode! Some brands have already launched their offers, others are going live later this week, and then we’ve got the madness of next week to look forward to! LOL. At this point, I think I’m running purely on Diet Coke, sugar and tea! @Meriem
90% of our clients are ecom. 30% have launched for Black Friday already… so it is on. Selling…
- EV accessories
- high tech water bottles
- Lego case
- Mountain Bikes
- Clothings: PJs and Athletic Wear
You name it, we sell it @duanebrown
Q2: Are you doing anything specific during the BFCM (Black Friday Cyber Monday) period this year?
Sidebar – the fact that it is still called Cyber Monday will never not make me cackle. @NeptuneMoon
Buying tons of stuff for myself. I mean gifts, buying gifts…..We (optmyzr) usually do a discount around that time for people who aren’t having very much fun optimizing. also going to be watching closely to see if agentic makes any impact, what the tROAS people are seeing etc. but thankfully not watching budgets like a hawk. @Aaronlevy
I am super interested to see how this year’s BFCM period stacks up, both because of AI but also the terrible economy @NeptuneMoon
Well, trying to schedule as much as possible ahead of time because I intend to take most of next week off LOL @ynotweb
I’ve heard mixed results from many for oct/nov so my spidey senses say people are saving for gift time/discounts @Aaronlevy
Make as many client as much money as possible and not go insane. @duanebrown
@NeptuneMoon pretty sure its going to super suck. And I have one client that made some poor business choices that makes this BF make-or-break. I already told our CPA not to expect that income come January. @ynotweb
The offers are decent that have already been rolling in, so I am curious how/if they will change next week for all the mailing lists I am apparently on… @NeptuneMoon
Feel like there’s been a little less of a focus here than in past years – to people’s points, the sales are starting earlier and going for longer…@revaminkoff
Sleeping??? LOL Mostly keeping a close eye on performance, budgets, stock levels and making sure everything is running as it should be. We’ve done a lot of the prep already, so hopefully it’s more monitoring and reacting than firefighting! Also getting all the Christmas ads ready to go live straight after too… Still waiting on some! One of my clients sent an influencer some free products this year, and she’s created a video that’s basically their very own Christmas ad and it’s SO CUTE!!! @Meriem
Well all the holiday seasons are both condensed and longer at the same time?!? Like holiday things have been in retails stores for over a month already @NeptuneMoon
Navah Hopkins the human is doing all the shopping at Critical Roll’s Critmas sale @navahhopkins
I think the companies that can afford to will make great offers and the companies that are hanging on a thread will not. Its just like anything when the economy is bad— when you invest in marketing and gaining customers, you survive. When you don’t, you don’t. @ynotweb
For me outside of work, I’m just counting down to Christmas so I can have a few days of eating, relaxing, crocheting and getting away from the computer for at least 1 day @Meriem
Navah Hopkins, Microsoft Advertising employee is super plugged into how we can make life easier. @navahhopkins
@navahhopkins A watch to pause time? A pokey stick to poke clients to make there final decisions and it being there final decisions?!!??! @Meriem
I think it totally makes sense that companies are starting earlier with all the “Learning Mode”/LLM optimizing that is required! You can’t put a campaign up last minute anymore and get the traction you need. @ynotweb
Which is bonkers because Google documentation acts like you won’t trigger learning mode with a budget change now???? Be serious. @NeptuneMoon
Accurate Google documentation?? Get real @ynotweb
@NeptuneMoon I’ve been scaling up spend all month, explaining to my jumpiest client that we cannot dump 200% more money into campaigns and expect anything good to come out of it @rebeccawarne
Let me see if I can find the one I just saw @NeptuneMoon
Companies always start early…. it’s like they hover over the button…. Like who’s going to launch first and GO GO GO… @Meriem
Always learning but never learning @Aaronlevy
Yes, sort of. My alcohol retailer is reminding everyone that they are THE destination for holiday plans, and our major telco would like to sell you mobile plans, something absolutely everyone does on Black Friday without fail. Didn’t Google create those short-term lifetime search campaigns for exactly this purpose? I’m not clear on their learning periods. @JuliaVyse
See… Alcohol companies should target people working in retail and marketing in Q4…@JuliaVyse like we are a prime market LOL @Meriem
@JuliaVyse I wasn’t familiar with short-term lifetime search campaigns. Is this them? If so, good to know about them! https://searchengineland.com/google-introduces-total-campaign-budgets-for-search-467573 @JonDeNunzio
Ok it was @MenachemAni who tweeted about it: @NeptuneMoon
@Meriem but can you afford the cognac I’d like to sell you? And NO, we are NOT putting US products back on the shelves just because it’s xmas. have some class everyone! @JonDeNunzio yes! this is a cool and interesting product that I’m excited about, and I do think this is purpose built for BFCM @JuliaVyse
@JuliaVyse I can see use cases for some of my B2B clients as well — like when they want to increase visibility around an industry event. @JonDeNunzio
And for new product launches! it’s a good and I think underused/underdiscussed option @JuliaVyse
Q3: Is your strategy different for this year’s BFCM period? If so, how is it different and if not, why not?
I’m super interested if folks have been uploading their full product catalogs this year where they might not have previously (given AI surfaces represent free additional exposure regardless of ad buys) @navahhopkins
Not really, but to be fair, this is ecom’s time to shine. @JuliaVyse
Well, I had the clients I had last year MORE prepared and had to educate the clients I took on since last year at the last minute. Its always something. but as for strategy, I am dividing more campaigns and more audiences to get higher coverage. @ynotweb
Some started selling earlier to beat competitors. Otherwise, try to keep it simple and put your best offer forward. @duanebrown
More price oriented – or at least, aware that consumers are more price oriented than years past. Yeah, definitely pushing people to redo their feeds to take full advantage of everything AI has to offer. @revaminkoff
Yes! I’ve been pushing a LOT harder for creative assets this year. Last year it was more “if you’ve got them, great” whereas this year it’s “I NEED your social assets for PMax and Demand Gen please!” Videos? Yes please! Oooo pretty statics? I’ll have those too LOL! I’m also reminding everyone that BFCM all sits in November this year and keeping an eye on ALL channels, not just mine. If there are gaps, can we plug them, But more importantly, why are they happening in the first place… IT’s all gooo basically LOL @Meriem
Talking about AI a bunch more too. @revaminkoff
But do you have a ChatGPT Business Hub account Yet….@revaminkoff LOL @Meriem
Q4: How are client/stakeholder expectations this year for BFCM? Similar to most years or different in some way?
Deep breath, PEOPLE DON’T BUY PHONE PLANS ON BLACK FRIDAY! STOP IT! @JuliaVyse
My luxury vacation client had a tough year last year due to climate change so the stakes are higher this year, but my primary point of contact is a reasonable human who understands that I do not control the weather @rebeccawarne
A4 definitely higher stakes this year for a few. see aforementioned “bad business decisions”. Some of my ecomms are actually settling in to the bump it gives them, so actual extra budget and stuff. @ynotweb
@rebeccawarne I have two luxury travel former clients who had their best years ever with me, incl 2020 Holiday when NO ONE was travelling. We should compare notes. @JuliaVyse
I still want to know who’s buying those cars for their significant others with no planning and putting a big bow on it. I am neither a client nor a stakeholder but I anticipate a GOOD q4 since I’m guessing there’s lots of pent up economic demand and bc companies are gonna try to make up for a soft year with price-led sales. (I hope.) @Aaronlevy
I think expectations are even higher this year! We need to go harder, deliver more, but with the same budgets as last year! There’s definitely more pressure on PPC to pick up the slack when other channels aren’t performing, but there’s only so much we can do! I’m spending a lot more time with clients to look at the bigger picture and be realistic about what we can achieve with the budgets we have. @Meriem
@Aaronlevy I would be mildly furious if my SO bought me a new car without discussion since it would drive up my insurance and registration costs @rebeccawarne
Those car ads have been head scratchers since forever @NeptuneMoon
I do not have an SO which would make it even more confusing and uncomfortable. I am however, happy to see that fragrance retailers have not changed their creative or their strategies for the last 90 years and continue to have random celebrities makin’ naughty noises to sell their juice. @Aaronlevy
OOOOO @Aaronlevy there IS a reason for those fragrance commercials! In the early 90’s, Armani hired David Lynch to make him a short film and gave him total creative freedom (why???) so David did his thing and created the Who Is Georgio spot. It makes NO sense, has nothing to do with fragrance, and is generally luxurious and weird. And Armani loved it, so now all fragrance commercials are bizarre. @JuliaVyse
Yes @Aaronlevy but we in PA also get to enjoy the vintage 80s PA Lottery holiday ads too! @NeptuneMoon
KEEP ON SCRATCHIN @Aaronlevy
Awww Gus the Groundhog @NeptuneMoon
@JuliaVyse so because david lynch decided to get all lynchian (philly represent!) we now have to stare at leo’s ear for some reason every commercial break? @Aaronlevy
I will take that over political ads any day – though the fragrance ads are objectively weird. Like does anyone want to smell like Johnny Depp? I am seriously asking @NeptuneMoon
@Aaronlevy yes. yes I am saying that. @JuliaVyse
I have to go to Ulta today – the teen is out of 2 critical hair products – I will report back on the fragrance ads/signage @NeptuneMoon
Q5: What is your biggest concern or worry for this year’s BFCM period? Is it different from years past?
I am not working on any accounts doing any kind of BFCM push, but I do think the horrible economy is going to be a major factor in sales this holiday season. Also, all of these outages have people freaked out @NeptuneMoon
I’m not worried, except feel bad for the aforementioned ‘bad-decisions’ client. I can only do my part. Definitely more worried about all the hacking activity more than I am BF. @ynotweb
On a personal level, I am concerned about folks trying to keep up with the Joneses and overspend. I will still do some buying for my circle, but I’m prioritizing my financial health (which is very hard as a bargain shopper who gets a dopamine rush from snagging a great deal) @rebeccawarne
Yesterdays Optimizely hack has me more worried about doing business online. Not sure other people have that worry yet @ynotweb
That is very troublesome and we should all be worried @NeptuneMoon
Unrelated, but I finally froze my credit report at all 3 agencies + Chex a couple weeks ago. It took 30 minutes @rebeccawarne
I have been dragging my feet on updating my phone but I think I am going to have to in light of all this crap @NeptuneMoon
literally factory resetting mine now because it’s a piece of crap because everyone outsourced their development to ai and it breaks every 4 secondsss. but yes, also curious about bad actors, what fraud level looks like. also curious how many people try to use muse or instinct and it fails and leads to a really disappointed (or excited) kid who gets a full sized fire truck instead of a hess truck. @Aaronlevy
Been paring down my digital footprint and hardening personal security for months, but still don’t feel prepared for what I’m expecting @ynotweb
But more seriously, expecting advertisers to get twitchy, i hope it’s not SO twitchy that it throws a wrench in the auction system. @Aaronlevy
My whole conversation with Governments is ‘yes cybersecurity’ and ‘yes, bad actors are moving swiftly with ai’ @JuliaVyse
Pattern recognition and a degree in International Politics can keep a girl up at night these days…@NeptuneMoon
@Aaronlevy who needs advertisers to throw wrenches when Google already threw enough this year @ynotweb
And does anyone else feel like platform changes are happening more often and closer to this critical ecomm window this year? @NeptuneMoon
It does feel that way @JuliaVyse
On that note, let me compliment @navahhopkins MS for being a real trooper – its helped some of my clients move budget to more productive platform than Google @ynotweb
“more often” imo is the ai effect, my chrome updates like 2x a day now. something we’re dealing with at optmyzr too. we CAN build tools so much faster, but 1: how do we communicate it 2: how do people use them 3: are we overwhelming people with too much stuff (probably). imo platforms have…. not asked themselves those questions @Aaronlevy
I think changes to the underpinning of a platform (Google with their new AI model) being injected into search now is bananas. But platforms are making decisions for stock prices and overall market impression and not for advertisers @NeptuneMoon
Not PPC-related, but this thread has me thinking harder about my personal digital security. I have been so busy lately I haven’t stopped to consider it, but you all make good points. @JonDeNunzio
1 tip: Delete apps and accounts you don’t use. @ynotweb
Honestly, I’m worried about brands putting too much pressure on BFCM to make up for the rest of the year. I just want to do the best we can for their accounts, but there’s only so much we can do and as someone who’s running a business myself, I get it! This year feels SO much more stressful than previous years. I feel more responsible than ever for my smaller clients because of how tough the market is right now, and that genuinely makes me sad. I just really want them to do well! @Meriem
“Accounts I don’t use” — OMG. So many. @JonDeNunzio
A client does not pay an invoice because it was not a good sale season. @duanebrown
Never been more grateful to be on retainer.. @ynotweb
PPCChat Participants
- Julie F Bacchini @NeptuneMoon
- Kammy Caruss @ynotweb
- Rebecca Warne @rebeccawarne
- Reva Minkoff @revaminkoff
- Aaron Levy @Aaronlevy
- Meriem @Meriem
- Duane Brown @duanebrown
- Navah Hopkins @navahhopkins
- Julia Vyse @JuliaVyse
- Jon DeNunzio @JonDeNunzio
Related Links



Stop the wasted ad spend. Get more conversions from the same ad budget.
Our customers save over $16 Million per year on Google and Amazon Ads.